Employers / News and insights

The counter-offer dilemma: Should you stay or should you go?

The counter-offer dilemma: Should you stay or should you go?

Congratulations! You've been offered a new job and have decided to accept it. It's an exciting step in your career, which shows that your skills and expertise are in demand. However, just as you've made your mind up, your current employer surprises you with a counter-offer. While it might be tempting to stay, it's essential to carefully consider the pros and cons before making your decision. As an experienced recruitment agency, we’re here to help you navigate this sticky situation.


The pros of accepting a counter-offer:


1.      Financial gain

Generally, counter-offers come with an increase in your current salary or benefits. Your employer may offer you more money, a bonus, or another incentive in an effort to get you to stay. That can be particularly enticing, especially if you were initially leaving for better compensation.


2.      Comfort and familiarity:

Staying with your current employer means you won't have to deal with settling into a new workplace if, like lots of us, you find it a little daunting. You already know the role, company culture, colleagues, and the work environment.


3.      No disruption:

Changing jobs can be disruptive. If you accept the counter-offer, you won't have to go through the inconvenience of quitting, transitioning and building new relationships with colleagues and clients.


The cons of accepting a counter-offer:


1.      Trust and loyalty:

Accepting a counter-offer may lead to a perception of disloyalty by your employer. They might wonder if you'll consider leaving again, which could affect your career progression.


2.      Temporary fix:

Counter-offers are often a short-term solution to a long-term issue. If your main reasons for wanting to leave your current job were related to culture, work-life balance, lack of opportunities for progression, then a counter-offer won't address these underlying problems.


3.      Career growth:

It’s likely your new role came with the promise of career growth, including new responsibilities or challenges. Staying with your current employer could actually limit your professional development and the chance to grow within your field.


4.      Burned bridges:

Rejecting a job offer after initially accepting it can damage your reputation with the potential employer and within the industry. Consider the long-term complications this decision could have on your professional relationships.


While a counter-offer may seem attractive at first glance, it's crucial to think beyond the immediate financial gains and consider your long-term career goals and personal growth. Before making a decision, have an open and honest conversation with both your current and potential employers about your priorities and concerns. Ultimately, the decision should align with your career aspirations and bring you closer to achieving your professional dreams.